Blog > Barrie's Culinary Gems: My Top 10 Favourite Restaurants
Barrie's Culinary Gems: My Top 10 Favourite Restaurants
Taste Buds, Prepare for Takeoff!
Barrie is a beautiful city known for its waterfront, parks, and cultural attractions. It might not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of culinary hotspots, but trust me, this hidden gem is a foodie's paradise! I have compiled a list (in no particular order) of my personal top 10 favourite restaurants that you must visit while in Barrie.
- Donaleigh's Irish Public House
28 Dunlop St E. | 705-735-3552 | donaleighs.com
Where the Irish Hospitality Meets Culinary Magic
Kickstarting our list is the authentic Irish pub and heart and soul of Barrie, Donaleigh's. Known for its warm atmosphere and hearty Irish fare, this pub never fails to charm. When you step inside, it just feels like a home away from home. They serve classic pub fare like fish and chips, bangers and mash, and shepherd's pie. They also have an extensive selection of beer, whiskey, and cocktails. Don't miss out on my absolute favourite lobster mac and cheese or share some of the famous nachos with someone (or don’t share, I won’t tell) – it's comfort food at its finest.
- PIE Wood Fired Pizza Joint
11 Victoria St | 705-503-7653 | piewoodpizza.com
Because Who Doesn't Love Pizza with a Wood-Fired Twist?
Prepare your taste buds for a pizza experience like no other at PIE Wood Fired Pizza Joint. If you're craving pizza, this is the perfect place to satisfy your hunger, it’s where the art of pizza-making meets innovation. Located in downtown Barrie, the restaurant's pizzas are made with fresh, local ingredients and cooked in a wood-fired oven. They also offer gluten-free and vegan options. Indulge in their mouthwatering Neapolitan-style pizzas, and be sure to try my top faves: St Lucia (if you are pro-pineapple) and Cluck Norris pie (for the pineapple haters of the world).
3. Casa Mia Ristorante
88 Dunlop St E. | 705-737-3663 | casamiaristorante.com
Greek and Italian Bliss in the Heart of Barrie
Transport yourself to Italy without leaving Barrie. Once you step into this charming eatery, be prepared to be engulfed in a symphony of heavenly scents a true celebration of authentic Italian AND Greek cuisine. The ambiance, as inviting as a Tuscan villa, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. From perfectly cooked pasta to heavenly tiramisu, each dish is crafted with love and precision, a true celebration of flavors. The ambiance is as inviting as the food is delightful and truly makes you feel like you’re at home. Be sure to head over on Friday or Saturday for their succulent, perfectly cooked Prime Rib Dinner takes center stage. This is not just a meal; it's a sensory celebration of irresistibly tender, melt-in-your-mouth perfection.
- Kenzington Burger Bar
40 Dunlop St E, | 705-725-1667 | kenzington.ca
Burgers That Define Perfection
For the burger aficionados, Kenzington is the place to be. 2 words: burger bliss! Craft your own masterpiece or savor one of their signature creations. The burger joint's commitment to perfection is evident in every bite. Trust me; you'll never look at a burger the same way again. It is the only spot I go for burgers and beer. They offer a selection of gourmet burgers, each one made with high-quality beef and served with a side of hand-cut fries.
Hawaii Five-O is my go to for here (sorry guys, I am PRO-PINEAPPLE on everything!) but sometimes I do also enjoy the Hot Honey Chicken. It’s so hard to decide that my hubby and I usually order both and “sharesies” them. Be prepared to redefine your burger expectations with a visit to Kenzington.
5. Il Buco Ristorante
31 Dunlop St E. | 705-735-9595 | ilbucoristorante.com
Elevating Fine Dining in Barrie
Il Buco is where sophistication meets flavour. This Italian gem, located in the heart of Barrie, has a warm and welcoming atmosphere that makes it perfect for a romantic evening, a date night, a family dinner or a special celebration. They offer a modern take on traditional Italian dishes, including pasta, seafood, and meat dishes. When I’m here, you will always find Chicken Marsala on my plate but their Osso Buco is a must-try! Every dish showcases the chef's dedication to delivering an unforgettable Italian dining experience, so you won’t be disappointed.
6. North Restaurant
49 Mary St | 705-734-0001 | northrestaurant.ca
Contemporary Elegance Meets Culinary Genius
Embark on a journey of contemporary elegance at North Restaurant. Chef and Owner Marco Ormonde says “Feed the soul, not the hunger”. I feel like that totally sums up the experience you have when going here. They present a repertoire of signature dishes and exclusive nightly features that extend beyond the confines of the menu. It is a chic destination for those seeking modern cuisine. Their ever-evolving menu and commitment to quality ensure a memorable dining experience. I can’t even begin to tell you my favourite dish here because it is literally different every time and if you’re craving something unique, let them know and they will craft a masterpiece tailored just for you!
7. Michael & Marion's
60 Collier St | 705-735-9968 | michaelandmarions.com
A Quaint Hideaway for Comfort Food
Michael & Marion's is a quaint little hideaway, and is the embodiment of food excellence. From the “creation of the moment” soup to the 40oz tomahawk steak, this cozy spot feels like a warm hug. The menu reflects a dedication to crafting comforting dishes that leave you with a sense of nostalgia and satisfaction. Chilled asian noodle salad, beet goat cheese and spinach risotto and whipped cheesecake…need I say more?
8. The Farmhouse Restaurant
268 Bradford St | 705-797-1006 | thefarmhouse.ca
Farm-to-Table Magic in Barrie
The Farmhouse is where the ingredients shine! Experience farm-to-table dining at its best and savour dishes that celebrate local ingredients with dishes that highlight the region's agricultural bounty. Delight your senses with a dining adventure that connects you with the essence of Barrie's culinary landscape. Farm fresh breakfast is served every Saturday and Sunday 10am-2pm but if you find yourself there any other time, get yourself a beef dip or the pan seared salmon.
- The Lazy Tulip Cafe
29 Maple Ave | 705-252-0910 | lazytulipcafe.com
Your mindful haven for fresh and conscious eating
Savour the cozy atmosphere at this delightful spot downtown Barrie. The Lazy Tulip Cafe is known for its warm community feel, and offers a diverse menu featuring everything from hearty breakfast options to mouthwatering lunches. A perfect place to unwind and indulge. They take pride in offering a menu brimming with wholesome, health-conscious choices. Everything is crafted in-house, from the whole wheat focaccia sandwich bread to the always-vegan and gluten-free soups. Grab yourself a London fog tea and a falafel wrap or Buddha bowl for the best lunch ever!
- Grillicious Restaurant & Wine Bar
2 Marsellus Dr Unit 1 & 2, Barrie | 249-388-3149
For Culinary Excellence and Wine Connoisseurs
Discover the culinary gem of Barrie at Grillicious Restaurant & Wine Bar. This establishment is a symphony of flavours, blending culinary mastery with a curated wine selection. The inviting ambiance sets the stage for intimate dinners and celebrations alike. A true family style Restaurant that crafts so many mouth watering options.From signature dishes showcasing their grilling expertise to an extensive wine list, Grillicious promises an unforgettable dining experience. I find it impossible to resist the white wine butter shrimp paired with peppercorn steak or a classic fish and chips. Or for those seeking a night off of cooking but want to stay in consider the family take-out special. It's the perfect solution for a quick and easy dinner to bring home.
Barrie, Ontario, is a culinary gem with a lot to offer. In my personal opinion, each restaurant on this list is a testament to the city's vibrant and diverse food scene. From Irish charm to wood-fired pizza perfection, or whether you're in the mood for comfort food or fine dining cuisine, you're sure to find a restaurant that caters to your needs. These ten restaurants come highly recommended by locals and visitors alike, and they're definitely worth checking out if you're in the area. You won't be disappointed by the quality of food and service. And with plenty of outdoor seating options, you can soak up the beautiful scenery while enjoying your meal, during the warmer months of course. Barrie boasts a strong food culture and continues to attract new restaurants that push the boundaries of traditional Canadian cuisine. So, whether you're a first-time visitor or a longtime resident, make sure to explore the city's culinary scene and sample some of its delicious offerings. Bon appétit!